Millions Recovered

  • $5,400,000.00 settlement involving a seaman who fell from a stairway during fire and boat drill aboard a container ship sustaining quadriplegic injuries. Partners Mellusi and Shisha personally inspected the vessel taking hundreds of measurements and still and videos of every stairway in the ship’s main deck house. The data was compared with the vessel’s design plans in our library which demonstrated the vessel had been negligently constructed in that it failed to follow the naval architect’s original design specifications.
  • $4,400,000.00 jury award to a former shipmate who sustained a shoulder injury while at sea. The third mate had to undergo multiple surgeries and will not be able to become a captain because of the injury.
  • $2,400,000 jury award to a licensed marine engineer who sustained permanent knee injuries while attempting to remove a 200 lb. valve from an overhead piping system. Partner Mellusi personally inspected the ship’s engine room taking detailed photos and measurements. A duplicate valve was obtained from a maritime junkyard and was brought into court along with an auto-shop mechanical hoist capable of lifting it 12 feet to demonstrate the vessel lacked suitable means to perform this work safely. The jury award was in top ten verdicts in the United States for a comparable knee injury. The case was tried to verdict in a New York Federal Court.
  • $2,980,000.00 jury award to a ship’s cook for back injury resulting from insufficient procedures for moving ship stores. Case tried in New York federal court.
  • $2,700,000.00 settlement to a mate on a Tanker vessel who sustained multiple fractures.
  • $2,000,000.00 was awarded to a barge deckhand – wrongful death.
  • $1,827,000 awarded to a marine engineer working on a US Government supply vessel who fell into an unguarded ventilation fan causing neck, shoulder and hand injuries. The case was tried non-jury before a federal judge in Baltimore Federal Court. The court award was subsequently determined to be within the highest ten verdicts for the State of Maryland in 2009.
  • $1,200,000.00 jury award to a ship’s Bosun who sustained shoulder and neck injuries while attempting to move plywood sheets on main deck of vessel during 40 knot winds. Case tried in New York Federal Court.
  • $950,000 awarded to passenger killed when his recreational boat came into collision with tow wire of tug and barge
  • $850,000 settlement, Federal Court Allentown PA., to seaman sustained herniated disk while lifting a 110 lbs crane hooks.
  • $840,000 jury award to a seaman who fell from ladder while painting sustaining fractured wrist.
Practice Areas Menu

Report: Crew fatigue likely caused Hudson River tugboat sinking

If you work on the water, you are probably familiar with working hard while short on sleep. But exhaustion can affect your judgment and lead to disaster, especially when coupled with bad weather and other challenges.

It now appears that crewmember fatigue was one of the main causes of the tugboat Specialist sinking last year. Three crewmembers died in the March 2016 accident, which occurred when the tugboat collided with the Tappen Zee Bridge construction site along the Hudson River north of the Bronx. The Specialist, while working with two other tugs to transport a barge with a crane on board, struck a construction barge near the bridge. Nearby workers noticed the accident and responded as quickly as possible but were unable to save any of the men on board the Specialist.

The National Transportation Safety Board recently released its report on the causes of the sinking. According to the report, the root problem was not having enough crew on board. This led to a situation where the existing crewmembers had worked multiple days in a row without enough sleep. The captain of the Specialist was helping at the helm of another insufficiently manned tug, the Realist, when the accident occurred.

According to investigators, it appeared that none of the crewmembers on either vessel could have had more than four or five hours of sleep at a time in the three days before the accident, and possibly longer. While short on sleep, the crewmembers had also faced difficult weather, poor visibility and strong currents, all of which contributed to their fatigue.

The captain and crewmembers of the Specialist were experienced mariners, but extreme fatigue likely affected their judgment. The NTSB report noted that the Specialist was increasing its speed as it approached a bridge, and that the mate incorrectly believed they had enough clearance to safely pass the construction barge.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

Let Us Help You

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Maritime FAQ

How do I know if I need an attorney?

Because of the complexities of Admiralty and Maritime Law, virtually all situations involving bodily injury and death require a timely consult with experienced maritime counsel.

Get More Answers

Rated By Superlawyer Ralph J Mellusi Rated By Superlawyer Ralph J Mellusi
Rated By Superlawyer Ralph J Mellusi Rated By Superlawyer Ralph J Mellusi
Rated By Sfpracuperlawyer Ralph J Mellusi Rated By Superlawyer Ralph J Mellusi